| Year |
Award |
Award ceremony |
| 2000 |
Best Performance in a TV Movie or Pilot - Supporting Young Actress (The Soul Collector) |
Young Artist Awards |
| 2003 |
Rising Star Award |
Fort Myers Beach Film Festival |
| Teenager of the Year |
Rolling Stone |
| Choice Movie Breakout Star - Female (The Lizzie McGuire Movie) |
Teen Choice Awards |
| Big Breakthrough of 2003 |
VH1 Big in 03 Awards |
| 2004 |
Franchise's Performance Award |
DVD Awards |
| Favorite Female Singer |
Nickelodeon Kids' Choice Awards, USA |
| Best Newcomer |
TMF Awards, Netherlands |
| Fake ID Club award |
TRL Awards |
| Best Female Artist |
World Music Awards |
| Best Young Ensemble in a Feature Film (Cheaper by the Dozen) |
Young Artist Awards |
| 2005 |
Born to Lead Award |
COSMOgirl! Magazine Annual Awards |
| Favorite Movie Actress (A Cinderella Story and Raise Your Voice) |
Nickelodeon Kids' Choice Awards, USA |
| Choice Movie Blush Scene |
Teen Choice Awards |
| Best Sister Style (Hilary and Haylie Duff) |
US Weekly Hottest Hollywood Style Awards |
| 2006 |
Best New Artist |
TRL Awards (Italy) |
| 2007 |
People's Choice: Favourite International Artist |
MuchMusic Video Awards (MMVAs) |
| First Lady |
TRL Awards (Italy) |
| Choice Love Song - With Love |
Teen Choice Awards |
| Best International Act |
Kids Choice Awards (Italy) |